Aetna vs. UnitedHealthcare Medigap Comparison

Written by: 
Matt Kiggins
Last updated: 
Nov 5, 2026

Aetna and UnitedHealthcare are two major Medicare Supplement insurance companies, but they don't always compete the same way on price.

I compared their Plan G premiums across 41 states at ages 65, 70, and 75.

I also compared their Plan N premiums.

The results show some important differences, especially for older applicants.

No items found.
Find Plans in Your Area
Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Quick Answer

Aetna and UnitedHealthcare sell the same standardized Medigap plans, so an Aetna Plan G covers the same Medicare-approved costs as a UnitedHealthcare Plan G.

The real differences are premium, discounts, how each company prices as you age, and which insurer actually issues your policy.

Plan G (current rates): UnitedHealthcare was lower in 36 of the 41 states I could compare at age 65 — but that lead shrank to roughly a coin flip by age 75.

Plan N (August 2026 rates): Aetna was lower in 31 of the 38 states I could compare.

Neither company wins everywhere, so the smart move is to quote both for your ZIP code, your age, and the plan letter you want.

Aetna vs. UnitedHealthcare Medicare Supplement at a Glance

ComparisonAetnaUnitedHealthcare
Medigap brandSold through Aetna-affiliated insurersAARP Medicare Supplement plans, insured by UnitedHealthcare or an affiliate
Plan G and Plan N benefitsStandardizedStandardized
Doctors and hospitalsAny provider nationwide that accepts MedicareAny provider nationwide that accepts Medicare
Membership requiredNoYes, AARP membership
Household discountsOffered in many states; amount and rules vary by issuing companyHousehold or multi-insured discounts in many states; rules vary
How pricing changes with ageUsually rises with age; depends on the state and policyOften starts lower, with an enrollment discount that shrinks over time in many states
Plan G, my current sample (age 65)Lower in 5 of 41 statesLower in 36 of 41 states
Plan N, my August 2026 sampleLower in 31 of 38 statesLower in 7 of 38 states

What Actually Separates Aetna and UnitedHealthcare Medigap

Because Medigap plans are standardized by plan letter, the company name on the card doesn't change what's covered.

What does change is who's behind the policy and how the price is built.

Aetna's Medigap Business

"Aetna Medigap" isn't one insurance company.

Aetna sells Medicare Supplement plans through several affiliated insurers, including Aetna Health and Life Insurance Company, American Continental Insurance Company, Continental Life Insurance Company of Brentwood, Tennessee, and Accendo Insurance Company.

Which one issues your policy depends on your state, and that can change the plan letters offered, the household discount, the underwriting questions, and the rate history.

When I quote Aetna, I always check the exact issuing company on the outline of coverage rather than relying on the Aetna name alone.

For a closer look at Aetna on its own, see my Aetna Medicare Supplement Plan G review.

UnitedHealthcare's AARP Medigap Plans

UnitedHealthcare's Medigap plans are sold as AARP Medicare Supplement plans, and you need to be an AARP member to enroll.

In many states, UnitedHealthcare offers an enrollment discount to people who sign up close to when they become eligible — and that discount shrinks year by year as you age.

That's why a UnitedHealthcare quote at 65 can look great, then climb faster than you expect.

Depending on the state, you may also see a household or multi-insured discount and a small discount for paying by automatic bank draft.

Other Differences Worth Comparing

Price gets most of the attention, but a few other things are worth checking before you pick either company.

  • The exact underwriting company: the insurer named on your application and outline of coverage is the one that sets your rates and pays your claims, so confirm it for both quotes.
  • State-specific discounts: household, multi-insured, and payment discounts differ by state and issuing company, so ask which ones apply to you and how long they last.
  • Pricing method: a policy can be priced by attained age, issue age, or community rating, and that affects how your premium can change as you get older.
  • Rate history: your state insurance department can often tell you how much a company has raised Plan G or Plan N rates in recent years.
  • Complaint information: your state insurance department and the NAIC publish complaint data by insurance company, which is more useful than a brand-wide reputation.

I don't name a financial-strength or service winner without dated, state-specific evidence.

My rate methodology

Plan G: current rates, nonsmoker, no household discount, one sample ZIP code per state, at ages 65, 70, and 75.

The headline Plan G numbers use a male applicant; I ran the same comparison for a 65-year-old female applicant and got the same 36-to-5 split.

Plan N: rates collected in August 2026 for a 65-year-old male nonsmoker with no household discount, one sample ZIP per state.

I don't have updated Plan N rates yet, so the Plan N results are clearly dated and may not match what you're quoted today.

These are sample averages across the locations I picked, not national market averages, and your own quote will depend on your age, gender, tobacco use, ZIP code, and discounts.

Plan G: UnitedHealthcare Was Lower in 36 of 41 States (Current Rates)

At age 65, UnitedHealthcare had the lower Plan G premium in most of the states where I had a rate for both companies.

36 / 41States UHC was lower at 65 (88%)
$225.65 vs $256.17Avg. UHC vs. Aetna Plan G at 65

The biggest UnitedHealthcare Plan G differences at 65:

Oregon $147.33Colorado $145.88New Hampshire $88.63Illinois $82.23Louisiana $69.06

The 5 states where Aetna was lower at 65:

North Dakota $24.76Idaho $18.77Arkansas $4.28South Dakota $3.02New Mexico $0.51

Several states, including Georgia, Kansas, Montana, Nevada, and Pennsylvania, were within $6 a month at 65.

The Plan G Gap Shrinks as You Age

This is the finding I'd pay the most attention to.

When I ran the same states at ages 70 and 75, UnitedHealthcare's lead got much smaller.

AgeUHC lowerAetna lowerAvg. UHCAvg. Aetna
6536 states5 states$225.65$256.17
7029 states11 states (1 tie)$253.42$276.14
7521 states20 states$301.40$317.75

Current Plan G rates, male nonsmoker, no household discount, same 41 states at each age.

The average gap dropped from about $31 a month at 65 to about $16 at 75.

UnitedHealthcare's declining enrollment discounts may help explain some of the narrowing.

However, state pricing methods and each company's rate structure also affect the results.

Comparing current premiums at 65, 70, and 75 shows you how each company's pricing is structured.

These aren't forecasts of what you'll pay later, since insurers can change rates and discounts.

My Plan G cost guide compares more companies at ages 65, 70, and 75.

Plan N: Aetna Was Lower in 31 of 38 States

The pattern flips for Plan N.

31 / 38States Aetna was lower (82%)
$170.93 vs $191.84Avg. Aetna vs. UHC Plan N

The biggest Aetna Plan N differences:

Kansas $66.19Vermont $64.01Mississippi $58.71New Mexico $49.76Georgia $48.56

UnitedHealthcare was lower on Plan N in 7 states, led by Oregon at $80.07 a month, while Virginia was nearly tied at $1.74.

Someone who only looked at Plan G could wrongly decide UnitedHealthcare is always the cheaper Medigap company.

What the State-by-State Rates Tell Me

Oregon

UnitedHealthcare was about $150 a month lower on Plan G at every age, and lower on Plan N too.

Montana

UnitedHealthcare was $2.17 lower on Plan G at 65, but Aetna was $49.50 lower at 75 and lower on Plan N.

Florida

UnitedHealthcare was $27.61 lower on Plan G at 65, nearly tied at 70, and $14.22 higher at 75.

Georgia

Plan G was close at 65 and tied at 70, then Aetna pulled ahead at 75 and on Plan N.

Idaho

In my Idaho sample, each company's Plan G premium stayed the same at ages 65, 70, and 75.

Aetna was $18.77 per month cheaper at every age.

Texas

UnitedHealthcare was $20.42 lower on Plan G at 65 but only $1.23 lower at 75, while Aetna was $35.50 lower on Plan N.

Sample States: Which Company Was Lower?

StatePlan G at 65Plan G at 75Plan N (Aug 2026)
FloridaUHC by $27.61Aetna by $14.22Aetna by $21.68
TexasUHC by $20.42UHC by $1.23Aetna by $35.50
CaliforniaUHC by $32.44UHC by $46.79UHC by $3.07
PennsylvaniaUHC by $0.79Aetna by $11.86Aetna by $36.77
OhioUHC by $20.29UHC by $18.52Aetna by $37.98
GeorgiaUHC by $5.99Aetna by $35.61Aetna by $48.56
OregonUHC by $147.33UHC by $149.58UHC by $80.07
MontanaUHC by $2.17Aetna by $49.50Aetna by $29.79

Monthly difference, male nonsmoker, no household discount. Plan G uses current rates. Use the tool below for every state.

Compare Aetna vs. UnitedHealthcare in Your State

See Plan G at ages 65, 70, and 75, plus Plan N, for your state.

Plan G: current rates · Plan N: collected August 2026

Pick a state to see how Aetna and UnitedHealthcare compared in my rate samples.

Alabama ZIP 35242

G 65UHC $218.51 · Aetna $279.72UHC lower by $61.21

G 70UHC $240.20 · Aetna $296.96UHC lower by $56.76

G 75UHC $294.43 · Aetna $349.11UHC lower by $54.68

N 2026UHC $163.76 · Aetna $127.53Aetna lower by $36.23

Alaska ZIP 99654

G 65UHC $206.80 · Aetna $238.15UHC lower by $31.35

G 70UHC $255.73 · Aetna $252.32Aetna lower by $3.41

G 75UHC $304.67 · Aetna $297.71Aetna lower by $6.96

N 2026UHC $179.44 · Aetna $186.18UHC lower by $6.74

Arizona ZIP 85142

G 65UHC $227.81 · Aetna $250.07UHC lower by $22.26

G 70UHC $250.42 · Aetna $273.39UHC lower by $22.97

G 75UHC $306.93 · Aetna $306.13Aetna lower by $0.80

N 2026UHC $183.74 · Aetna $180.93Aetna lower by $2.81

Arkansas ZIP 72764

G 65UHC $217.86 · Aetna $213.58Aetna lower by $4.28

G 70UHC $217.86 · Aetna $213.58Aetna lower by $4.28

G 75UHC $217.86 · Aetna $213.58Aetna lower by $4.28

N 2026UHC $169.83 · Aetna $133.45Aetna lower by $36.38

California ZIP 92336

G 65UHC $223.12 · Aetna $255.56UHC lower by $32.44

G 70UHC $275.88 · Aetna $309.21UHC lower by $33.33

G 75UHC $328.64 · Aetna $375.43UHC lower by $46.79

N 2026UHC $165.20 · Aetna $168.27UHC lower by $3.07

Colorado ZIP 80134

G 65UHC $216.56 · Aetna $362.44UHC lower by $145.88

G 70UHC $267.78 · Aetna $383.55UHC lower by $115.77

G 75UHC $319.01 · Aetna $451.15UHC lower by $132.14

N 2026UHC $199.60 · Aetna $222.49UHC lower by $22.89

Connecticut ZIP 06902

Plan GNo comparable Aetna rate

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Delaware ZIP 19720

G 65UHC $208.90 · Aetna $220.41UHC lower by $11.51

G 70UHC $229.65 · Aetna $233.91UHC lower by $4.26

G 75UHC $281.51 · Aetna $274.81Aetna lower by $6.70

N 2026UHC $171.85 · Aetna $136.95Aetna lower by $34.90

Florida ZIP 34787

G 65UHC $287.93 · Aetna $315.54UHC lower by $27.61

G 70UHC $343.91 · Aetna $344.20UHC lower by $0.29

G 75UHC $397.73 · Aetna $383.51Aetna lower by $14.22

N 2026UHC $232.10 · Aetna $210.42Aetna lower by $21.68

Georgia ZIP 30043

G 65UHC $223.00 · Aetna $228.99UHC lower by $5.99

G 70UHC $263.25 · Aetna $263.25Tied

G 75UHC $313.25 · Aetna $277.64Aetna lower by $35.61

N 2026UHC $198.25 · Aetna $149.69Aetna lower by $48.56

Hawaii ZIP 96706

Plan GNo comparable Aetna rate

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Idaho ZIP 83646

G 65UHC $278.75 · Aetna $259.98Aetna lower by $18.77

G 70UHC $278.75 · Aetna $259.98Aetna lower by $18.77

G 75UHC $278.75 · Aetna $259.98Aetna lower by $18.77

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Illinois ZIP 60629

G 65UHC $217.75 · Aetna $299.98UHC lower by $82.23

G 70UHC $239.36 · Aetna $317.96UHC lower by $78.60

G 75UHC $293.40 · Aetna $373.68UHC lower by $80.28

N 2026UHC $202.65 · Aetna $182.34Aetna lower by $20.31

Indiana ZIP 47906

G 65UHC $219.27 · Aetna $258.40UHC lower by $39.13

G 70UHC $241.04 · Aetna $273.89UHC lower by $32.85

G 75UHC $295.45 · Aetna $321.87UHC lower by $26.42

N 2026UHC $204.33 · Aetna $170.85Aetna lower by $33.48

Iowa ZIP 50023

G 65UHC $197.37 · Aetna $230.32UHC lower by $32.95

G 70UHC $219.12 · Aetna $244.40UHC lower by $25.28

G 75UHC $255.37 · Aetna $287.22UHC lower by $31.85

N 2026UHC $178.53 · Aetna $163.93Aetna lower by $14.60

Kansas ZIP 66062

G 65UHC $218.50 · Aetna $223.74UHC lower by $5.24

G 70UHC $242.77 · Aetna $237.65Aetna lower by $5.12

G 75UHC $283.23 · Aetna $278.97Aetna lower by $4.26

N 2026UHC $216.05 · Aetna $149.86Aetna lower by $66.19

Kentucky ZIP 40475

G 65UHC $214.09 · Aetna $239.74UHC lower by $25.65

G 70UHC $235.34 · Aetna $280.05UHC lower by $44.71

G 75UHC $288.48 · Aetna $320.29UHC lower by $31.81

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Louisiana ZIP 70726

G 65UHC $229.49 · Aetna $298.55UHC lower by $69.06

G 70UHC $252.26 · Aetna $316.96UHC lower by $64.70

G 75UHC $309.19 · Aetna $372.35UHC lower by $63.16

N 2026UHC $171.39 · Aetna $200.50UHC lower by $29.11

Maine ZIP 04401

Plan GNo comparable Aetna rate

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Maryland ZIP 20906

G 65UHC $255.87 · Aetna $300.21UHC lower by $44.34

G 70UHC $281.24 · Aetna $318.71UHC lower by $37.47

G 75UHC $302.37 · Aetna $374.52UHC lower by $72.15

N 2026UHC $212.56 · Aetna $193.59Aetna lower by $18.97

Massachusetts

Massachusetts uses its own Medigap system, so a Plan G/N comparison doesn't apply.

Michigan ZIP 48197

G 65UHC $198.08 · Aetna $226.33UHC lower by $28.25

G 70UHC $217.76 · Aetna $240.07UHC lower by $22.31

G 75UHC $266.96 · Aetna $282.05UHC lower by $15.09

N 2026UHC $174.59 · Aetna $147.36Aetna lower by $27.23

Minnesota

Minnesota uses its own Medigap system, so a Plan G/N comparison doesn't apply.

Mississippi ZIP 38654

G 65UHC $186.52 · Aetna $200.50UHC lower by $13.98

G 70UHC $207.30 · Aetna $212.91UHC lower by $5.61

G 75UHC $241.94 · Aetna $250.15UHC lower by $8.21

N 2026UHC $198.99 · Aetna $140.28Aetna lower by $58.71

Missouri ZIP 63376

G 65UHC $269.25 · Aetna $301.81UHC lower by $32.56

G 70UHC $337.50 · Aetna $331.57Aetna lower by $5.93

G 75UHC $378.00 · Aetna $375.80Aetna lower by $2.20

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Montana ZIP 59901

G 65UHC $230.32 · Aetna $232.49UHC lower by $2.17

G 70UHC $284.77 · Aetna $246.82Aetna lower by $37.95

G 75UHC $339.22 · Aetna $289.72Aetna lower by $49.50

N 2026UHC $200.72 · Aetna $170.93Aetna lower by $29.79

Nebraska ZIP 68516

G 65UHC $244.13 · Aetna $261.48UHC lower by $17.35

G 70UHC $268.34 · Aetna $275.81UHC lower by $7.47

G 75UHC $328.87 · Aetna $323.95Aetna lower by $4.92

N 2026UHC $225.22 · Aetna $185.26Aetna lower by $39.96

Nevada ZIP 89110

G 65UHC $251.30 · Aetna $256.90UHC lower by $5.60

G 70UHC $276.21 · Aetna $272.56Aetna lower by $3.65

G 75UHC $338.50 · Aetna $320.21Aetna lower by $18.29

N 2026UHC $197.47 · Aetna $179.26Aetna lower by $18.21

New Hampshire ZIP 03103

G 65UHC $219.75 · Aetna $308.38UHC lower by $88.63

G 70UHC $267.00 · Aetna $338.28UHC lower by $71.28

G 75UHC $321.50 · Aetna $283.76Aetna lower by $37.74

N 2026UHC $204.25 · Aetna $220.91UHC lower by $16.66

New Jersey ZIP 08701

G 65UHC $237.23 · Aetna $299.88UHC lower by $62.65

G 70UHC $263.54 · Aetna $336.53UHC lower by $72.99

G 75UHC $307.40 · Aetna $400.67UHC lower by $93.27

N 2026UHC $208.72 · Aetna $200.84Aetna lower by $7.88

New Mexico ZIP 87121

G 65UHC $191.60 · Aetna $191.09Aetna lower by $0.51

G 70UHC $212.72 · Aetna $191.09Aetna lower by $21.63

G 75UHC $247.92 · Aetna $219.75Aetna lower by $28.17

N 2026UHC $157.63 · Aetna $107.87Aetna lower by $49.76

New York ZIP 11368

Plan GNo comparable Aetna rate

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

North Carolina ZIP 27587

G 65UHC $186.79 · Aetna $208.25UHC lower by $21.46

G 70UHC $205.36 · Aetna $220.91UHC lower by $15.55

G 75UHC $251.79 · Aetna $259.73UHC lower by $7.94

N 2026UHC $176.73 · Aetna $143.36Aetna lower by $33.37

North Dakota ZIP 58104

G 65UHC $279.91 · Aetna $255.15Aetna lower by $24.76

G 70UHC $310.88 · Aetna $288.97Aetna lower by $21.91

G 75UHC $362.50 · Aetna $337.78Aetna lower by $24.72

N 2026UHC $205.49 · Aetna $186.34Aetna lower by $19.15

Ohio ZIP 45011

G 65UHC $204.79 · Aetna $225.08UHC lower by $20.29

G 70UHC $225.13 · Aetna $238.90UHC lower by $13.77

G 75UHC $275.98 · Aetna $294.50UHC lower by $18.52

N 2026UHC $180.84 · Aetna $142.86Aetna lower by $37.98

Oklahoma ZIP 73099

G 65UHC $227.81 · Aetna $243.74UHC lower by $15.93

G 70UHC $250.42 · Aetna $259.98UHC lower by $9.56

G 75UHC $306.93 · Aetna $304.38Aetna lower by $2.55

N 2026UHC $197.47 · Aetna $168.60Aetna lower by $28.87

Oregon ZIP 97229

G 65UHC $260.53 · Aetna $407.86UHC lower by $147.33

G 70UHC $302.87 · Aetna $457.42UHC lower by $154.55

G 75UHC $376.25 · Aetna $525.83UHC lower by $149.58

N 2026UHC $193.07 · Aetna $273.14UHC lower by $80.07

Pennsylvania ZIP 19120

G 65UHC $263.10 · Aetna $263.89UHC lower by $0.79

G 70UHC $292.24 · Aetna $280.22Aetna lower by $12.02

G 75UHC $340.81 · Aetna $328.95Aetna lower by $11.86

N 2026UHC $178.71 · Aetna $141.94Aetna lower by $36.77

Rhode Island ZIP 02860

G 65UHC $199.30 · Aetna $211.50UHC lower by $12.20

G 70UHC $219.10 · Aetna $224.08UHC lower by $4.98

G 75UHC $268.60 · Aetna $264.48Aetna lower by $4.12

N 2026UHC $155.99 · Aetna $130.53Aetna lower by $25.46

South Carolina ZIP 29072

G 65UHC $193.86 · Aetna $211.83UHC lower by $17.97

G 70UHC $215.44 · Aetna $224.99UHC lower by $9.55

G 75UHC $251.42 · Aetna $264.31UHC lower by $12.89

N 2026UHC $174.59 · Aetna $138.53Aetna lower by $36.06

South Dakota ZIP 57106

G 65UHC $243.67 · Aetna $240.65Aetna lower by $3.02

G 70UHC $267.84 · Aetna $272.39UHC lower by $4.55

G 75UHC $328.25 · Aetna $318.54Aetna lower by $9.71

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

Tennessee ZIP 37013

G 65UHC $188.01 · Aetna $221.24UHC lower by $33.23

G 70UHC $206.70 · Aetna $234.74UHC lower by $28.04

G 75UHC $253.43 · Aetna $275.81UHC lower by $22.38

N 2026UHC $171.39 · Aetna $157.94Aetna lower by $13.45

Texas ZIP 77494

G 65UHC $239.56 · Aetna $259.98UHC lower by $20.42

G 70UHC $263.32 · Aetna $275.64UHC lower by $12.32

G 75UHC $322.72 · Aetna $323.95UHC lower by $1.23

N 2026UHC $197.77 · Aetna $162.27Aetna lower by $35.50

Utah ZIP 84043

G 65UHC $236.81 · Aetna $245.32UHC lower by $8.51

G 70UHC $260.30 · Aetna $260.23Aetna lower by $0.07

G 75UHC $319.03 · Aetna $306.04Aetna lower by $12.99

N 2026UHC $182.06 · Aetna $169.02Aetna lower by $13.04

Vermont ZIP 05401

Plan GNo comparable Aetna rate

N 2026UHC $287.75 · Aetna $223.74Aetna lower by $64.01

Virginia ZIP 22193

G 65UHC $197.62 · Aetna $236.07UHC lower by $38.45

G 70UHC $217.25 · Aetna $250.57UHC lower by $33.32

G 75UHC $266.34 · Aetna $294.30UHC lower by $27.96

N 2026UHC $166.36 · Aetna $168.10UHC lower by $1.74

Washington ZIP 99301

Plan GNo comparable Aetna rate

N 2026No comparable Aetna rate

West Virginia ZIP 26554

G 65UHC $212.72 · Aetna $267.48UHC lower by $54.76

G 70UHC $233.84 · Aetna $282.80UHC lower by $48.96

G 75UHC $286.64 · Aetna $333.20UHC lower by $46.56

N 2026UHC $193.20 · Aetna $179.18Aetna lower by $14.02

Wisconsin

Wisconsin uses its own Medigap system, so a Plan G/N comparison doesn't apply.

Wyoming ZIP 82001

G 65UHC $227.36 · Aetna $250.73UHC lower by $23.37

G 70UHC $249.92 · Aetna $284.14UHC lower by $34.22

G 75UHC $306.32 · Aetna $331.87UHC lower by $25.55

N 2026UHC $211.50 · Aetna $179.93Aetna lower by $31.57

Male nonsmoker, no household discount. "G 65" means Plan G at age 65. ZIP shown is the Plan G sample; Plan N may use a different ZIP. Your premium may differ.

Where my samples had no comparable rate

I didn't have an Aetna Plan G rate for Connecticut, Hawaii, Maine, New York, Vermont, or Washington in my current sample.

My August 2026 Plan N sample had no Aetna rate for Connecticut, Hawaii, Idaho, Kentucky, Maine, Missouri, New York, South Dakota, or Washington.

Those are gaps in my rate collection, not proof that Aetna doesn't sell there.

Massachusetts, Minnesota, and Wisconsin use their own Medigap plan systems, so Plan G and Plan N comparisons don't apply.

Want rates for your actual ZIP code and age?

My samples show the pattern, but your real premium depends on your own details and discounts.

Compare Aetna and UHC Quotes

Which Company Is Right for You?

Consider Aetna if:

  • You want Plan N — Aetna was lower in 31 of 38 states in my sample
  • You're 70 or older and Aetna's Plan G is close to or below UHC's in your state
  • You don't want to pay for an AARP membership
  • You qualify for the household discount offered by the Aetna company in your state

Consider UnitedHealthcare if:

  • You're turning 65 and want Plan G — UHC was lower in 36 of 41 states at that age
  • You've looked at current rates for older ages, not just the price at 65
  • You're already an AARP member
  • You and a spouse or household member both qualify for a multi-insured or household discount

If neither company is competitive in your state, see the Medigap companies I'd compare first.

I've also compared UnitedHealthcare against HealthSpring and Blue Cross Blue Shield.

Questions to Ask Before You Enroll

  • What's my actual premium for my age, gender, tobacco status, and ZIP code?
  • Which company will actually issue my policy, and what pricing method does it use in my state?
  • For UnitedHealthcare, how much of my price is an enrollment discount, and how fast does it shrink?
  • What does this company currently charge 70- and 75-year-olds for the same plan in my state?
  • Has this company's Plan G or Plan N premium in my state jumped in recent years?
  • Am I in my Medigap Open Enrollment Period or do I have a guaranteed-issue right, or will I need to answer health questions?

Aetna vs. UnitedHealthcare Medigap: My Verdict

My recommendation is to compare both companies for the same Medigap plan in your ZIP code.

UnitedHealthcare was more competitive for Plan G at age 65 in my research, while Aetna performed better for Plan N.

But don't choose based on the company name alone.

Compare the issuing insurer, available discounts, current premiums at different ages, and recent rate history before deciding.

FAQ

It depends on the plan, your age, and your state. In my research, UnitedHealthcare was usually lower for Plan G at age 65, while Aetna was usually lower for Plan N. Compare both for the same plan in your ZIP code before deciding.

Yes. Medigap plans are standardized, so Plan G from either company covers the same Medicare-approved costs. Massachusetts, Minnesota, and Wisconsin use their own standardized plans.

Standard Medigap plans from either company don't use networks, so you can see any doctor or hospital in the U.S. that accepts Medicare. The exception is a Medicare SELECT policy, which UnitedHealthcare offers in some states and which requires network hospitals for non-emergency care.

Yes. UnitedHealthcare's Medicare Supplement plans are sold as AARP Medicare Supplement plans, and AARP membership is required to enroll. Aetna doesn't require any membership.

Usually not, unless you're in your Medigap Open Enrollment Period or have a guaranteed-issue right. Outside those situations, the new company can ask health questions and decline your application. A few states have their own rules that let you switch at certain times without underwriting, so keep your current policy until the new one is approved.

Matt Kiggins
Matt Kiggins
Senior Editor
SimpleAdvisor.com

For over 15 years, Matt Kiggins has been the senior editor at Simple Advisor, giving detailed advice on Medicare, life insurance, and dental coverage to thousands of clients in more than forty states. His demonstrated expertise in assisting people with their health plan selection is remarkable — it’s evident that he stands out among competitors as the go-to source for knowledge and support.

Matt holds a resident 2–15 Florida Health & Life (Including Annuities & Variable Contracts) Agent License in Florida, his state license number is P116762 (Issued 10/1/2007).

Read Full Bio
Matt Kiggins
Matt Kiggins
Senior Editor
SimpleAdvisor.com
Insurance Licenses & Lines of Authority

Matt Kiggins is the producer appointed to oversee the content written on SimpleAdvisor.com.

Every agent representing PG holds a state-issued producer license for the states they serve.

Below is a list of Matt's active state license numbers:

Alabama

Alaska

Arizona

Arkansas

California

Colorado

Connecticut

Delaware

Florida

Georgia

Idaho

Illinois

Indiana

Iowa

Kentucky

Louisiana

Maine

Maryland

Michigan

Minnesota

Mississippi

Missouri

Montana

Nebraska

Nevada

New Hampshire

New Jersey

New Mexico

North Carolina

Ohio

Oklahoma

Oregon

Pennsylvania

Rhode Island

South Carolina

South Dakota

Tennessee

Texas

Vermont

Virginia

West Virginia

Wisconsin

Wyoming

755279

3001965232

9559070

9559070

0H72252

519936

9559070

3001965305

P116762

3072590

932489

9559070

3799890

9559070

911784

709135

PRN419941

3001965303

9559070

40593901

10859393

3001965230

100159294

9559070

3191612

9559070

N1623228

9559070

9559070

1439768

100254887

9559070

790297

3001965331

9559070

40642669

2331396

1585860

3001965244

822139

9559070

9559070

322182

Need Help?

Call to speak with a licensed insurance agent now.

(888) 414-4547

Or enter your zip code to shop online

Thank you! Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.
Get Quote