Best Medicare Supplement Companies Compared (2027)
After comparing thousands of Medicare Supplement quotes, we've learned that most people start with the wrong question: "Which company is best?"
The better question is, "Which company is most competitive right now for my ZIP code, my age, and the plan I want?"
Someone calls almost every week asking for their neighbor's company — but the neighbor's ZIP code, age, and health may be nothing like yours, so we start with quotes, not brand names.
Which Medicare Supplement Companies Are Worth Comparing?
There's no single best Medicare Supplement company for everyone, because the same plan letter provides the same standardized benefits no matter which company sells it in most states.
That said, these are the seven companies we compare most often today:
| Company | Why we compare it | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| HealthSpring | Lowest Plan G price in more of our sample states than any other carrier | Newer brand name; household discount not offered in every state |
| Mutual of Omaha | One of our first quotes for High-Deductible Plan G; streamlined electronic application | Often among the highest standard Plan G prices in our sample |
| Physicians Mutual | Innovative Plan G — a different plan design, not just a different price | Not available everywhere; best suited to long-term owners |
| UnitedHealthcare (AARP) | Largest Medigap carrier; gym membership included where available | Requires AARP membership; price varies widely by state |
| Florida Blue | Florida-based company with local offices and age-locked pricing | Starting premium can be higher, though pricing is built for long-term owners |
| Humana | Lowest Plan G price in 8 of our sample states | Among the highest prices in other states |
| Aetna | Long Medigap history and a well-known name | Lowest price in only one of our 46 sample states |
Based on the quote sample described later on this page, plus our own quoting experience.
How We Evaluate Medicare Supplement Companies
Because the coverage is standardized, we compare companies on what actually differs.
Medicare.gov confirms that Medigap plans with the same letter offer the same basic benefits, with Massachusetts, Minnesota, and Wisconsin standardizing plans differently.
Here's what we look at for every client:
- Current premium for your exact age, ZIP code, gender, and tobacco status.
- How the premium is priced and how it has changed, since the lowest price today isn't always the lowest price later.
- Underwriting, including how the company handles health questions if you're outside your Open Enrollment window.
- Financial strength of the specific insurance company that issues the policy, not just the brand on the card.
- Discounts and extras, which we treat as secondary to price.
- Product availability, since not every company sells every plan in every state.
Financial ratings apply to the legal insurer, and one brand can use several insurers depending on the state.
That's why we check the rating for the company named on your application rather than listing one rating per brand here — you can look it up on AM Best.
To make this list, a company also needs a long history in the Medicare Supplement market and must be one we regularly quote for real clients.
With some carriers leaving the Medigap market in recent years, we've deliberately favored companies with a demonstrated long-term commitment to it.
Seven Medicare Supplement Companies We Compare Regularly
Each company below gets one profile — what we see when we quote it, where it falls short, and who should consider it.
HealthSpring: Competitive Plan G and Plan N Pricing
If your priority is simply finding one of the lowest premiums available, HealthSpring is usually one of the first companies we quote.
HealthSpring is the former Cigna Medicare Supplement business, which Health Care Service Corporation (HCSC) acquired in 2025.
HCSC completed the rebrand of its Medicare Supplement plans to HealthSpring in September 2026, and existing Cigna Medicare Supplement policyholders keep the same coverage and benefits under the new name.
What we like
- Lowest Plan G price in 27 of the 46 states in our sample
- Highest price in only one of those states
- Frequently competitive on Plan N in our quoting experience
- Household discount in many states
Watch out for
- Household discount varies by state and isn't offered in Hawaii, Idaho, Minnesota, or Vermont
- Its Healthy Rewards perk is a discount program, not a free gym membership
Worth a look if: you want the lowest standardized Plan G or Plan N premium and don't mind a less familiar brand name. See our HealthSpring Plan G review.
Mutual of Omaha: A Strong High-Deductible Plan G Option
Mutual of Omaha has shifted from being a standard Plan G leader to one of the first companies we quote for High-Deductible Plan G.
For standard Plan G, it was the highest-priced carrier in 20 of the 46 states in our sample, so we no longer assume it's the value pick there.
What we like
- Competitive High-Deductible Plan G pricing in many markets
- A largely electronic application, with quick decisions for many applicants
- Electronic policy and ID card delivery
- Household discount, which varies by state and policy series
Watch out for
- Standard Plan G is often among the highest prices we see
- A fast decision isn't the same as guaranteed approval — health questions still apply outside Open Enrollment
- Its Mutually Well fitness program is a paid add-on ($29.99/month), not a free perk
Worth a look if: you're leaning toward High-Deductible Plan G and want a simple, quick application process. See our Mutual of Omaha Plan G review.
Physicians Mutual: A Different Approach to Plan G
Physicians Mutual is one of the few companies we don't compare on price alone — we compare it because it sells a genuinely different version of Plan G.
With Innovative Plan G, you pay a plan deductible for your first three calendar years in exchange for a lower premium.
After the third calendar year, the plan deductible goes away and the policy pays like standard Plan G, while the rider's discounted pricing continues under the policy's terms.
That doesn't mean the premium never changes — it can still go up with approved rate increases.
No new application or health questions are needed for that change.
What we like
- Priced below the company's standard Plan G, with the discount continuing after the deductible ends
- A one-time option to switch plans within the first two years without health questions
- Optional Preventive Benefits Plus rider with Silver&Fit access for an added monthly cost
Watch out for
- Not available in every state, and only for first-time Physicians Mutual customers; rider and switching terms can vary by state
- Dropping the rider before year three moves you to the standard Plan G premium
- Its standard Plan G is often not the lowest price, so compare Innovative Plan G against other carriers' Plan G and High-Deductible Plan G
Worth a look if: you're healthy, expect to keep one policy for many years, and are deciding between standard Plan G and High-Deductible Plan G.
UnitedHealthcare: The Largest Medigap Carrier
UnitedHealthcare sells AARP-branded Medicare Supplement plans and has long been the largest Medigap carrier by enrollment.
In our sample, it was the lowest-priced Plan G in 7 of 46 states, including Michigan, Alaska, and Arizona for a 65-year-old.
What we like
- Available in nearly every state
- Renew Active gym membership at no additional cost on AARP plans insured by UnitedHealthcare, where available
- Competitive in certain states
Watch out for
- Requires an AARP membership and its separate annual fee
- Can be one of the higher prices in other states
Worth a look if: it prices competitively in your ZIP code, or you'll actually use the included gym membership. A bigger name alone doesn't buy better Plan G coverage. See how it stacks up in our HealthSpring vs. UnitedHealthcare and Aetna vs. UnitedHealthcare comparisons.
Florida Blue: Local Offices and Florida-Based Support
Florida Blue is Florida's own Blue Cross Blue Shield company, and it's one we compare for many of our Florida clients.
Its strengths are long-term pricing stability and local support — two things a lowest-price-today comparison can miss.
Its standard Medigap plans don't use a provider network; like any Medigap plan, you can see any doctor nationwide who accepts Medicare.
What we like
- In-person help at local Florida Blue Centers
- "Same Age Forever" locks your rating age at 65, so your premium doesn't rise just because you get older
- Discount for paying by automatic bank draft
- Now offers High-Deductible Plan G
Watch out for
- Same Age Forever doesn't prevent rate increases tied to healthcare costs or claims
- Starting premium was mid-pack in our Florida sample — third-lowest of six carriers for a 65-year-old
- SilverSneakers is available for an additional fee
Worth a look if: you live in Florida, want a local company you can visit in person, and want a premium that won't rise just because you get older.
Humana: Fitness and Wellness Features
Humana is more competitive than many people expect in certain markets, and less competitive in others.
In our sample, it was the lowest-priced Plan G in 8 states, including South Carolina and Mississippi — but the highest in 10.
What we like
- Lowest price in states such as Kentucky, Mississippi, Oklahoma, and South Carolina in our sample
- Some Humana Medigap policies include wellness extras, depending on policy and state
- Household discount, which varies by state and policy series
Watch out for
- Some of the highest prices in our sample, including Florida and California
- Extras vary — confirm what's actually included with your policy
Worth a look if: you live in a state where it prices well and you'll use the extras. See our Humana Medicare Supplement quote guide.
Aetna: A Long Track Record, Higher Pricing Today
Five years ago, Aetna would have been one of our most competitive recommendations.
Today, it was the lowest-priced Plan G in only one of the 46 states in our sample and the highest-priced in 15.
What we like
- A long history in the Medigap market
- Owned by CVS Health
- Household discount in many states
Watch out for
- Policies are issued by several Aetna-affiliated companies, so discounts and underwriting vary by state
- SilverSneakers is an Aetna Medicare Advantage perk, not a Medigap benefit
- Higher than several competitors in many of the states we sampled
Worth a look if: it happens to price well in your ZIP code. See our Aetna Plan G review.
What Our Medigap Quote Comparisons Show in Six States
We've compared these companies across thousands of Medicare Supplement quotes, and the price differences can be substantial.
To show how much premiums vary, we pulled actual Plan G quotes from six states using the same age and coverage assumptions.
How we collected these quotes
- Plan: Standard Plan G
- Applicant: 65-year-old female
- Tobacco: Non-tobacco rates
- Household discount: Not applied
- Effective date: January 1 of the upcoming plan year
- Location: One sample ZIP code per state, not a statewide average
- Carriers: HealthSpring, UnitedHealthcare, Humana, Aetna, Mutual of Omaha, and the local BCBS company where quoted
- Scope: 47 states quoted; MA, MN, and WI excluded because they standardize Medigap differently
Prices in a different ZIP code, at a different age, or with a household discount will differ.
Physicians Mutual's Innovative Plan G isn't included because its plan deductible makes it a different product to compare.
| Carrier | Texas 77494 | Florida 34787 | Pennsylvania 19120 | Michigan 48197 | South Carolina 29072 | Georgia 30043 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| HealthSpring | $172.60 | $201.19 | $186.91 | $207.39 | $183.44 | $198.12 |
| UnitedHealthcare | $212.11 | $264.77 | $210.43 | $175.51 | $171.46 | $197.50 |
| Humana | $217.63 | $281.56 | $221.28 | $175.80 | $148.01 | $214.05 |
| Mutual of Omaha | $215.65 | $245.63 | $248.26 | $202.69 | $163.27 | $255.71 |
| Aetna | $225.99 | $274.31 | $229.41 | $196.50 | $184.26 | $199.09 |
| BCBS company | $191.59 | $255.07 (Florida Blue) | Not quoted | Not quoted | Not quoted | $191.00 |
| Gap, lowest to highest | $53.39/mo ($641/yr) | $80.37/mo ($964/yr) | $61.35/mo ($736/yr) | $31.88/mo ($383/yr) | $36.25/mo ($435/yr) | $64.71/mo ($777/yr) |
Green = lowest price in that state's sample. Red = highest. Yearly gaps are sample quote differences, not guaranteed savings.
We chose these six states because they show the full picture — four different companies came out lowest.
When we ran the same ZIP codes for a 65-year-old male, the lowest-priced company was the same in all six states.
What the full sample shows
We ranked 46 of the 47 states we quoted — Vermont was left out because only two carriers returned quotes there.
These rankings show which insurer offered the lowest premium in our selected ZIP code for each state, not which company is cheapest throughout the entire state.
Here's how often each company came out lowest for a 65-year-old:
The local BCBS company was lowest in 2 states, and Mutual of Omaha and Aetna in one state each.
Three takeaways stand out to us:
- No company wins everywhere. HealthSpring led most often, yet it was the most expensive option in our Michigan sample.
- The spread is real money. In our Florida sample, the gap between lowest and highest was $80.37 a month — about $964 a year for identical Plan G benefits.
- Sometimes it's a near-tie. In Michigan, UnitedHealthcare beat Humana by just 29 cents a month, and in Georgia the four lowest-priced carriers landed within about $8 of each other — so service and rate history matter more than price.
For more state-by-state pricing, see our Medicare Supplement Plan G cost guide.
Why the Cheapest Medigap Company Today May Not Be the Cheapest Later
The question we hear most from people who already own a Medigap policy is, "Why did my premium go up so much?"
A low starting premium is only part of the story, because several things can change what you pay over time:
- How the policy is priced. With attained-age pricing, your premium rises as you age; with issue-age pricing, your age at purchase sets the rating age.
- Company-wide rate increases tied to healthcare costs and claims experience.
- Where you live, since rates are filed and adjusted state by state.
- Discount changes, such as some household discounts that end if your situation changes.
Our own data shows how age alone reshuffles the order.
In 11 of the 46 states we sampled, the company offering the lowest Plan G premium to a new 65-year-old applicant was different from the company offering the lowest premium to a new 75-year-old applicant.
These are current quotes at different ages, not projected increases for an existing policyholder.
Pricing method matters too: in our Florida sample, Florida Blue was about $54 a month higher than HealthSpring at 65.
Because Same Age Forever keeps your rating age at 65, that gap could narrow over time, although both companies can still raise rates for other reasons.
We've also watched company competitiveness shift with our own clients.
Aetna used to be near the top of our quote comparisons, Mutual of Omaha was far more competitive for standard Plan G, and HealthSpring wasn't winning as many comparisons as it does today.
A company's past rate increases can give useful context, but they can't predict what it will charge in the future.
How Medical Underwriting Affects Your Company Choices
Underwriting is one of the biggest reasons the "cheapest company" may not be available to you.
- During your Medigap Open Enrollment Period — the six months starting the month you're 65 or older and enrolled in Medicare Part B — companies generally can't deny you or charge more because of your health.
- Outside that window, most companies can ask health questions, and approval isn't guaranteed.
- Guaranteed issue rights apply in specific situations, such as losing other coverage through no fault of your own.
This matters most when you get a large rate increase letter and want to switch.
If you're outside Open Enrollment and don't have a guaranteed issue right, you'll usually need to pass underwriting with the new company first.
Never cancel your current policy until the new one has approved you in writing.
Two companies on this list handle underwriting differently in ways worth knowing:
- Mutual of Omaha uses a largely electronic process, and many applicants get a quick decision — but a quick decision is still a medical underwriting decision.
- Physicians Mutual lets many new policyholders switch once to another eligible Physicians Mutual plan within the first two years without answering health questions.
Underwriting rules vary by company and state and can change from year to year, so we confirm current rules before anyone applies.
How to Choose the Right Medicare Supplement Company
Here's the same process we use with our own clients:
- Pick the plan letter first. Decide between Plan G, Plan N, or High-Deductible Plan G before comparing companies — our Medicare Supplement comparison chart shows what each plan letter covers.
- Get quotes from several companies for that same plan. Use the same age, ZIP code, gender, tobacco status, and discount assumptions for every quote.
- Look past the starting price. Ask how each policy is priced and how its premiums have changed.
- Check whether you'll face health questions. If you're outside Open Enrollment, confirm you're likely to qualify before you apply.
- Treat extras as a tiebreaker. Fitness programs and discounts only matter if the prices are close and you'll actually use them.
The most common mistake we see is choosing a company by brand name and assuming a higher premium buys better coverage — for the same standardized plan letter, it doesn't.
How We're Compensated
We're an independent Medicare insurance agency, and we may receive compensation from the insurance company if you enroll through us.
You generally don't pay a higher Medigap premium for using our agency.
We don't rank companies by commission — our recommendations are based on price, underwriting, and long-term value.
Bottom Line
After 15+ years of helping Medicare beneficiaries, we've learned that the company you pick doesn't change your standardized coverage — it changes your price, how that price ages, and your underwriting.
So instead of asking which company is best, ask which one is most competitive right now for your ZIP code and plan.
FAQ
We focus on companies with an established history in the Medicare Supplement market (generally five years or longer), demonstrated financial stability, and continued value through pricing, underwriting, discounts, or unique plan features.
No. Medigap plan benefits are standardized by the federal government. A Plan N, Plan G, or Plan A policy from any company covers the same things — the differences between companies come down to price, underwriting, discounts, and service.
Yes, but outside your one-time Medigap Open Enrollment window, switching usually requires medical underwriting, and approval isn't guaranteed. Some states offer additional guaranteed-issue rights, so check your state's rules before assuming you can switch freely.
Not necessarily. Rate increases happen across every carrier, and a company's history of rate increases matters as much as its starting premium.
While many top Medicare Supplement companies focus on offering competitive rates and quality customer service, others like Aetna and Mutual of Omaha provide additional benefits. These benefits may include bundling final expense life insurance with Medicare Supplements or ancillary health insurance products for extra coverage.

For over 15 years, Matt Kiggins has been the senior editor at Simple Advisor, giving detailed advice on Medicare, life insurance, and dental coverage to thousands of clients in more than forty states. His demonstrated expertise in assisting people with their health plan selection is remarkable — it’s evident that he stands out among competitors as the go-to source for knowledge and support.
Matt holds a resident 2–15 Florida Health & Life (Including Annuities & Variable Contracts) Agent License in Florida, his state license number is P116762 (Issued 10/1/2007).

Matt Kiggins is the producer appointed to oversee the content written on SimpleAdvisor.com.
Every agent representing PG holds a state-issued producer license for the states they serve.
Below is a list of Matt's active state license numbers:
Alabama
Alaska
Arizona
Arkansas
California
Colorado
Connecticut
Delaware
Florida
Georgia
Idaho
Illinois
Indiana
Iowa
Kentucky
Louisiana
Maine
Maryland
Michigan
Minnesota
Mississippi
Missouri
Montana
Nebraska
Nevada
New Hampshire
New Jersey
New Mexico
North Carolina
Ohio
Oklahoma
Oregon
Pennsylvania
Rhode Island
South Carolina
South Dakota
Tennessee
Texas
Vermont
Virginia
West Virginia
Wisconsin
Wyoming
755279
3001965232
9559070
9559070
0H72252
519936
9559070
3001965305
P116762
3072590
932489
9559070
3799890
9559070
911784
709135
PRN419941
3001965303
9559070
40593901
10859393
3001965230
100159294
9559070
3191612
9559070
N1623228
9559070
9559070
1439768
100254887
9559070
790297
3001965331
9559070
40642669
2331396
1585860
3001965244
822139
9559070
9559070
322182
Or enter your zip code to shop online